Paul Scholes has voiced significant concerns about Manchester United’s direction under Erik ten Hag, asserting that the team is “regressing” due to inadequate coaching. Scholes claims that, two years into Ten Hag’s tenure, United appears to lack both progress and a coherent playing strategy, contrasting starkly with the upward momentum of rivals like Manchester City, Liverpool, and Arsenal.
Speaking with Mail Sport, Scholes argued that United’s inconsistent performances reflect a failure to instill a clear game plan. “It’s difficult to watch,” he said, adding, “The players look like they don’t understand what the manager wants from them.” Scholes noted that fans are increasingly disillusioned with the team’s lack of direction, which leaves United “far off” from being truly competitive.
A point of contention for Scholes was Ten Hag’s recent treatment of Marcus Rashford. After scoring three goals in two games, Rashford was unexpectedly dropped for the match against Crystal Palace. Scholes felt this decision damaged Rashford’s momentum and confidence, suggesting it was an odd move that left fans questioning the rationale behind it. He believes this highlights a broader issue with Ten Hag’s approach, which has undermined the team’s morale.
Scholes also criticised United’s recruitment strategy, which he claims lacks focus. Instead of targeting proven talent, Ten Hag’s signings include less experienced players like Rasmus Hojlund, whose impact remains uncertain. According to Scholes, United would have been wiser to invest in established stars such as Harry Kane or Declan Rice, whose skills and leadership qualities are better suited to stabilise the team. He argues that this failure in recruitment reflects a club without a clear vision.
As pressure mounts on Ten Hag, Scholes is concerned that United lacks the dynamism and consistency required to keep up with their top-flight competitors. With upcoming fixtures against Porto and Aston Villa, Scholes believes the club urgently needs a revival to meet fans’ expectations and restore their faith.